Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 88 reviews.
The brush was good, but the blush was too light.
Linda N.
3/5
Verified
November 5, 2026
Powder Perfect Color for Eyes and Cheeks - Sugar Cookie
Have ordered this product many times and very happy. However, if there is a problem and you need customer service...forget it! Customer service does not exist!!!!
Leah S.
5/5
Verified
October 12, 2026
Blue Angel Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
I thought it went on splotchy very hard to work with. I did watch the videos and I did buy your eyeliner brush.
Sunday G.
3/5
Verified
October 6, 2026
Black Beauty Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Great eyeliner. last all day without smudges.
Bonita S.
5/5
Verified
September 20, 2026
Black Beauty Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Love the softer shade…….better with my gray hair!!!
Erma R.
5/5
Verified
August 13, 2026
Steel Magnolia Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Color pigment is great wearability is fantastic!! Stay where you put it!
Great product!
Francie D.
5/5
Verified
August 4, 2026
Blue Angel Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Love this gel eyeliner!!!!!!!
Francie D.
5/5
Verified
July 30, 2026
Blue Angel Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
The brush is nice and thin which allows me to create a thin line with the gel eyeliner. It's perfect!
Kim E.
5/5
Verified
July 12, 2026
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
I like the makeup brushes and will keep them. Unfortunately the makeup primer, concealer/eye-makeup primer, and gel eye-liner did not work for me. The makeup primer did not improve the look of my skin before, or after, applying foundation. The eye primer/concealer did not provide a smooth solid base for my eye shadow, and the eye liner didn’t adhere well and smeared. Also, the green color of this liner was darker than it looked online and didn’t look attractive on me. The color looks almost black on me.
On the positive side, customer service has been responsive and helpful.
Tracey C.
5/5
Verified
June 6, 2026
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
I have hazel colored eyes, and this Mischievous shade brings out some different colors in them, not Brough out by other shades.
I alternate between this shade, and the Chocolate Kiss shade--a lovely medium brown
Janice C.
5/5
Verified
June 5, 2026
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Mischievous
This eyeliner is absolutely bomb!!! 💣 It’s so pigmented and lasts for hours on end! I highly recommend it. So many eyeliners have gone down the tubes, but never this one! I have it in 5 colors-Blue Angel, Steel Magnolia, Hunter, Chocolate Kiss and Black Orchid (the one I’m wearing in the video).
Andrea B.
5/5
Verified
May 16, 2026
Blue Angel Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
This pink mocha color is just right for me ❤️🥰
I know you will LOVE it too !!
Glenda K.
5/5
Verified
May 12, 2026
Powder Perfect Color for Eyes and Cheeks - Pink Mocha
Goes on smooth. Color very nice and stays on all day
Karen H.
5/5
Verified
March 25, 2026
Chocolate Kiss Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
I live this eye liner never leaves where you put it on
Anne S.
5/5
Verified
March 15, 2026
Amethyst Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Great eyeliner Luv it 💖
Patie L.
5/5
Verified
February 4, 2026
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
Very satisfied with your makeup and the simplicity it can be. And looking forward for what’s ahead.
Thank you !
Francie D.
5/5
Verified
December 11, 2025
Black Orchid Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Absolutely gorgeous makeup
Kristina K.
5/5
Verified
November 30, 2025
Powder Perfect Color for Eyes and Cheeks - Hot Crossed Bronze
I love this liner. I’ve never found a more creamy, easy to apply stay put gel liner.
Terri D.
5/5
Verified
November 8, 2025
Chocolate Kiss Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
The best make up I ever had!
Kristina K.
5/5
Verified
November 8, 2025
Pretty Perfect Set
It's the perfect size to apply liner. I've been looking for a product like this for some time! Found it! :)
Prince, J.
5/5
Verified
October 23, 2025
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
I love everything I get from Mommy Makeup! I have been wearing makeup forever so I have tried lots of brands. Mommy Makeup offers excellent quality at a reasonable price. So glad I found this company!!
Barbara G.
5/5
Verified
September 24, 2025
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
My favorite eyegel was discontinued, and I had gone through about 5 other products trying to find a replacement. Mommy makeup’s did the trick! Perfect!
Misty B.
5/5
Verified
August 15, 2025
Blue Angel Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
The Best eyeliner! Does not irritate and lasts all day!
Bonnie P.
5/5
Verified
August 11, 2025
Steel Magnolia Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
The color is great with very smooth, comfortable texture
Brenda S.
5/5
Verified
June 21, 2025
Line Smoothing Lip Gloss | Paraben-free Plumping Gloss - Golden Girl
I’ve tried many brands and types of eyeliners, but the Mommy Makeup Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner is my holy grail eyeliner. It goes on smooth, has a rich pigment and does not budge until I remove it. It lasts through tears, humidity and long days. I keep this in my makeup bag. The other colors are beautiful as well.
Kittie W.
5/5
Verified
April 9, 2025
Black Beauty Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
Nice product, great service 👍
Marianna F.
5/5
Verified
January 13, 2025
Chocolate Kiss Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments
I am so very pleased with this product! Goes on effortlessly and stays on!
Claire J.
5/5
Verified
January 9, 2025
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
Wow, I love this soft olive/brown/gold color. Never harsh looking, but really emphasizes my eyes. My new favorite!
Linda
5/5
December 13, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Olive It Up
I have tried many different brands of eyeliner! By far Mommy make up’s stay put eyeliner is the best!!
Debra M.
5/5
Verified
December 9, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Black Beauty
I love this brush, it makes applying the eyeliner very easy.
Barbara D.
5/5
Verified
November 20, 2024
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
After a few tries I finally have the correct colors for my cheeks and lips. Customer service was very helpful in exchanging my original shades.
Judith S.
5/5
Verified
November 2, 2024
Line Smoothing Lip Gloss | Paraben-free Plumping Gloss - Model Mauve
The eyeliner is very well pigmented and darker when applied. I love the blush; very pretty.
Angela J.
5/5
Verified
October 29, 2024
Eye Love It Set | Waterproof Eyeliner + 3-in-1 Color
Love this eyeliner! Goes on easily and looks great!
Linda D.
5/5
Verified
October 27, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Black Beauty
Super nice lipsticks!
Sarah G.
5/5
Verified
October 20, 2024
Line Smoothing Lip Gloss | Paraben-free Plumping Gloss - Pinkalicious
I love this eyeliner!! I already have it in Amethyst and I had to try it in different colors!! Chocolate Sizzle did not disappoint!!
Liz M.
5/5
Verified
October 13, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Chocolate Sizzle
Is perfect shade! Great pigmentation and light formula! Love it
Heidi D.
5/5
August 1, 2024
Line Smoothing Lip Gloss | Paraben-free Plumping Gloss - Bit of Honey
I HAVE ALLERGIES AND MY EYES WATER---THIS EYELINER STAYS ON AND THE POINTED BRUSH MAKESTHE APPLICATION EASY.
Donna R.
5/5
Verified
July 6, 2024
Pointed Eyeliner Brush
The blue eye shadow is my very favorite. It’s easy to apply and stays on all day. No smearing at all!
Becky H.
5/5
Verified
June 15, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Blue Angel
Amazing eyeliner, glides on easy, does not smudge!! Love it!!
Gail M.
5/5
Verified
June 9, 2024
Stay Put Waterproof Gel Eyeliner w/ Micropigments - Hunter
I love the multipurpose eyes shadow plus blush
The brushes was very useful for both eyeshadow and blush
Great product for busy mommies
Dede D.
5/5
Verified
June 1, 2024
Powder Perfect Color for Eyes and Cheeks - Peach Tartlet